Examining the attitude of nursing students of Gilan University of Medical Sciences towards academic dishonesty, neutralizing behaviors, nursing ethics codes and commitment to ethical care in 2010-2018.

Number of pages: 120 File Format: word File Code: 32051
Year: 2012 University Degree: Master's degree Category: Paramedical
  • Part of the Content
  • Contents & Resources
  • Summary of Examining the attitude of nursing students of Gilan University of Medical Sciences towards academic dishonesty, neutralizing behaviors, nursing ethics codes and commitment to ethical care in 2010-2018.

    statement of the problem

    Today, ethics is the focus and center of many developments in the current world. Humanity goes through different periods to have a rational and moral approach in meeting its material and spiritual needs. For this reason, ethics can be considered the focus and center of developments in the future world. This approach mostly affects the disciplines that are leading in providing services to humans. Nursing profession is one of the sciences that has many exemplary ethical aspects in the past, present and future. Nursing ethics is a branch of medical ethics that has been influenced by the developments in this field. The developments of the current world include features that have made the need for an ethical approach in medical professions an undeniable necessity ([i]).

    The nature of health services that deals with the valuable issue of preserving life and improving its quality and eliminating or reducing disease and disability in general and the field of nursing in particular is compatible with this trend and idea in service management. In other words, it can be said that the foundation stone and the original principle in providing nursing care worthy of today's society and the future world is the training of nurses who have professional ethics ([ii])

    Despite all the emphasis that has been placed on the need to prioritize ethics over any other phenomenon, what is currently observed in practice is doubt about the professional qualifications of nursing and other fields related to health ([iii]). Despite the growing and dynamic nursing system, there is a need for nurses with professional qualifications who can provide good and ethical care. This requires that nurses, in addition to having appropriate functional skills, have a high ability in moral reasoning and effective communication with the patient ([iv]).

    Nursing is providing care to needy clients, which requires the existence of an element of ethics as an integral part in all aspects of providing these services. Moral care is a universal need, because it is an important part in providing nursing care. Commitment to ethical care [1] is defined as the core of nursing values ??and shows the degree of concern for the patient and the level of respect for the patient's personality during nursing care. The importance of commitment to moral care is such that it sometimes surpasses the technical aspects of nursing work. This point is not just an impression and feeling that is caused by human nature and his tendency towards good character, but it is a logical issue, because paying attention to ethics in self-care will require continuous learning and doing good deeds ([viii]).

    In order to achieve this goal, we need to increase the ability of nurses in ethical matters, this ability is essential for nurses. For many years, ethical codes (confidentiality, respect for patient rights, honesty, etc.) have been developed in the world, and this shows the importance of ethics as one of the main elements of nursing ([ix]) Valuing ethical care in the nursing profession has brought nurses to the highest level of standards and their attitude and philosophy leads them to ethical commitment and accurate performance to support patients, but what exists as a fundamental challenge on the way to achieving commitment to ethical care is the existence of a phenomenon called scientific dishonesty[2]. is And according to the definition, it is any form of dishonesty that occurs in connection with official academic activities. Scientific dishonesty in the form of copying, forgery, destruction, etc. It has become a long-term challenge in higher education centers and for teachers, and its existence has been proven in many studies ([x]). Scientific dishonesty has become a growing phenomenon from the pre-student period to the student period, especially in nursing schools. Scientific dishonesty has become an acute issue for contemporary scientific centers, as it has been the subject of more than 100 researches in the past 30 years. ([xi])..

    According to McLafferty[3], every profession has a sacred purpose and honesty is an essential part of that profession for survival and progress. As a result, the issue of scientific dishonesty is a vital issue for professions because it reflects the growing concern about ethical problems in the world of work. Among all professions in the world, nursing is one of the most honest professions. In a census conducted in the United States in 2003, nursing had the highest ethical standards and work honesty among 23 professions. At such a high level of ethical expectations, it seems that scientific dishonesty does not exist in nursing programs, while nursing students commit acts of scientific dishonesty without knowing it as dishonesty ([xii]).

    Scientific dishonesty in scientific and clinical environments in related professions With health like nursing, it is very worrying because these professions affect the lives of other people ([xiii]). What worries nursing educators is that nursing students suffer from scientific dishonesty both in the classroom and in clinical environments (6) and this is because the moral behaviors of individuals in the workplace are correlated with their moral behaviors as students (7). Since the basis of communication between nurse and patient is based on honesty and correctness, the issue of scientific dishonesty is a big challenge because nurses are in direct contact with patients (6). Scientific dishonesty in the classroom has potentially serious effects on patients because if students commit scientific dishonesty in the classroom, they will not learn the skills and knowledge needed to perform safe care in clinical environments. From a scientific point of view, if nursing enters the field without sufficient knowledge, critical errors can occur, despite the fact that the nursing profession has a high level of honesty, a significant percentage of nursing students exhibit scientific dishonesty behaviors.

        Bowers [4] (1964) showed in his research that 26% of students commit academic dishonesty during the exam session. McCabe and Trevino [5] (2002) conducted this research on students again in 1993 and observed that this time 52% of students committed academic dishonesty. Due to the similarity of the samples, it can be argued that the level of academic dishonesty among students has increased (7). On the other hand, it is the foundation of an effective evaluation structure and system on mutual respect and honesty. Students and instructors must treat each other with respect and honesty, which forms the basis for teaching, learning, and evaluation. The incidence of scientific dishonesty such as copying, lying, etc. It can destroy the trust of instructors towards students ([xiv]). The scientific dishonesty of nursing students can seriously reduce the professional standards of nursing work, damage the cohesion of the scientific community of nurses and weaken the quality of the health system. Educators should be aware of various forms of scientific dishonesty of nursing students. (4). Patterson and others [6] (2003) showed that the opinions of professors and students about the phenomenon of copying as a part of scientific dishonesty are different. While the professors consider this phenomenon to be the result of the student's moral failure, the students see it as a characteristic of academic centers. Also, students consider copying as an action according to the situation and not due to dishonesty (5). Most students are aware of the effects of scientific dishonesty in the clinical environment on patients, but they are not aware of the effects of scientific dishonesty in the classroom and its transfer to clinical environments ([xv]). Some educational centers use ethical codes [7] of nursing (care for patients, confidentiality, honesty in behavior, maintaining nursing values, etc.) to combat the phenomenon of scientific dishonesty among students (8) Codes of ethics are ethical values ??in scientific and clinical environments that are part of the training program of nurses and are a prominent sign of the nursing profession ([xvi]) Gold[8] and colleagues in their research 4 main concerns of nurses in the field of ethical care of patients are lack of confidentiality of nurses, lack of fairness in care From the patients, they have expressed the failure to maintain moral values ??in care, the inability of nurses to recognize the ethical problems of care and the correct way to face them correctly ([xvii]).

  • Contents & References of Examining the attitude of nursing students of Gilan University of Medical Sciences towards academic dishonesty, neutralizing behaviors, nursing ethics codes and commitment to ethical care in 2010-2018.

    List:

     

    Chapter One: Generalities

    1-1 Research field 1

    1-2 Research objectives (general purpose and specific objectives)7

    1-3 Research questions7

    1-4 Definitions of words8

    1-5 Research assumptions9

    1-6 Research limitations10

    The second chapter: background and background of the research

    2-1 research framework 11

    2-2 overview of the conducted studies 25

    Chapter three: research implementation method

    3-1 type of research 47

    3-2 research community 47

    3-3 research samples 47

    3-4 sampling method and determination of sample size 47

    3-5 Characteristics of the research units 47

    3-6 Research environment 48

    3-7 Data collection tools 48

    3-8 Determining the scientific validity and reliability of data collection tools 50

    3-9 Data collection and analysis methods 50

    3-10 Ethical considerations 52

    Chapter four: Results Research

    4-1 Research findings 53

    4-2 Tables 54

    Chapter Five: Discussion and examination of findings

    5-1 Discussion and interpretation of research results 93

    5-2 Application of findings and suggestions for future research 102

    List of sources 106

    Appendices

    Questionnaire

    English abstract

     

     

    Source:

    [1] Horton, K., Taschudin V., Forget A. the value of nursing. A literature review. nurses ethics. 2007;14(6):716-740.

    [1] .Mallaber, C., Turner P. competence versus hours: an examination of a current dilemma in nursing education. Nurse educ today.2006;26(2):110-114.

    [1] .Hart, PA., Oslon DK., Fredrikson L., McGovern P. Competencies most valued by employers implications for master prepared occupational health nurses. AAOHN J.2006;54(7):327-335.

    [1] .Bjork, IT. what constitutes a nursing practical skill?. West J nurse res. 1999;21(1):51-70.

    [1] .Benner, MP. Value pluralism, moral competence, and nursing education. United States, Delaware: University of Delaware. 1985. [1] Cooper, MC. Principle-oriented ethics and the ethics of care: a creative tension. ANS Adv nurs sci.1991;14(2):22-31.

    [1] . Cook, P. R., & Cullen, J. A. Caring as an imperative for nursing education. Nursing Education Perspectives.(2003); 24(4): 192-197.

    [1] . Homai, Rahimi M. Examining the opinions of patients hospitalized in Hamedan teaching hospitals about the invasion of their personal territory in 2013. Summary of articles of the national conference on the quality of life in Tehran 2016, period 4 (number 54), pp: 25-21.

    [1] . Abbaszadeh, A., Abedi, H., Ghofranipour, F., Sharif, F. Designing and evaluating the moral performance model of nurses. Medicine and cultivation 1381, number 47, pp: 59-67.

    [1] McCrink, A. Nursing attitude towards academic misconduct, the code of ethics for nurses and their commitment to the ethics of caring. A dissertation submitted for the degree of Doctor of Education. Dowling college; 2008.

     

    [1] .Wideman, M. Caring, Sharing, Coping and Control: Academic Dishonesty and the nursing student. A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of philosophy. University of Toronto. Department of curriculum. Teaching and Learning Ontario Institute for studies in education; 2009.

    [1] Arhin Ottie, A., Jones, K. A multidiscipline exploration of college students' perceptions of academic dishonesty: Are nursing students different from other college students?. Nurse education today. 2009; 29:710-714.

    [1] . Langone M., Faculty perception of academic and clinical dishonesty in traditional honor code and non honor code nursing programs. A dissertation for the degree of doctor of philosophy in health sciences, college of health sciences of Touro International University, 2006.

     

    [1] . Gaberson, K., Academic dishonesty among nurturing students. Nursing Forum. 1997; 32(3): 2-14

    [1] . Baxter, PE ., Boblin, SL. The moral development of baccalaureate nursing students: Understanding unethical behavior in classroom and clinical settings. Journal of nursing education. 2007; 46(1): 20-27.

     

    [1] . Davidhizar, R. Honesty: The. Honesty: The best policy in nursing practice. Today's OR Nurse. (1992); 14(1): 30-34.

     

    [1] .Gold, C., Chambers, J., Devorak EM. Ethical dilemmas in the lived experience of nursing practice. Nurse ethics. 1995;2(2):131-142.

    [1] . Nasiriani, Kh., Fernia, F., Nasiriani, F. Examining the observance of patient rights from the point of view of nurses working in Yazd hospitals. Scientific Journal of Legal Medicine, 1386, Volume 13 (Number 1), pp: 37-33.

    [1] Dierckx, D., Casterle, B., et al. Nursing students' responses to ethical dilemmas in nursing practice. NursingEthics. (1997); 4(1): 12-28.

    [1] McCrink, A. Academic Misconduct in Nursing Students: Behaviors, Attitudes, Rationalizations, and Cultural Identity. Journal of Nursing Education. 2010;49(11):653-659.

    [1] Haines, VJ., et al. College cheating: Immaturity, lack of commitment and the neutralizing attitude. Research in Higher Education. (1986);  25(4): 342-354.

     

    [1] .McCabe, D., Academic dishonesty in nursing school: An empirical investigation. Journal of nursing education. 2009; 48(11): 614-623.

     

    [1] . Arvidson, C. J. The anatomy of academic dishonesty: Cognitive development, self-concept, neutralization techniques and attitudes toward cheating. Dissertation Abstracts International. (2004); 65: 08A. (UMI No. 3144972).

     

    [1] . Wolf, Z. R., Hoerst, B. Professional commitment in RN-BSN and Basic BSN Students. Nurse Educator, 2007, 32(2), 61-65.

    [1] Abdi, H., Heydari, A., Salsali M. Experiences of nursing graduates from professional preparation during the transition to their clinical role. Iranian Journal of Education in Medical Sciences, 1383, Volume 4 (Number 12), pp: 78-69.

    [1] Dierckx de Casterle, B., Grypdonck, M., Cannaerts, N. Steeman E. Emprical ethics in action: Lesson from two empirical studies in nursing ethics. Med health care philos. 2004;7(1):31-39.

    [1] . Abbaszadeh, A., Abedi, H., Ghofranipour, F. Designing and evaluating the moral performance model of nurses. Medicine and cultivation, 1381, number 47, pp: 67-59.

    [1] . Berhani, F., Abbaszadeh, A. Medical team and responsibility of nurses. Abstract of the articles of the first International Congress of Medical Law of Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences. May 25-23, 1386, p.: 31. [1] Berhani, F., Al-Hani, F., Mohammadi, A., Abbaszadeh A. Explaining the meaning of moral competence of nurses in patient care. Abstract of the articles of the 10th Asian Conference on Bioethics and the 4th UNESCO Asia-Pacific Conference on Ethics. Tehran University of Medical Sciences, May 6-9, 1388, p:28. [1] Conner, M., Sparks, P. Ambivalence and attitudes.  European Review of Social Psychology. (2002);   12:70-73.

    [1] . Sheppard, B.H., Hartwick, J., Warshaw, P.R. The theory of reasoned action: A meta-analysis of past research with recommendations for modifications and future research. Journal of Consumer Research. 1988;15: 325–343.

    [1] . Ajzen, I. The theory of planned behavior. Org. Behav. Hum. Decide. Process. (1991); 50: 179–211. [1] Mortaz, S., Gershasbi A. A review of the basics of ethics and medical ethics. Bimonthly scientific-research journal of Daneshvar Medical, 18th year, number 90, December 2019, pp: 1-11.

    [1] Misbah, M. The most fundamental ideas: a selection of the foundations of Islamic thought. Qom: Publications of Imam Khomeini Educational and Research Institute (RA), 1390, first edition.

    [1] Beikzad, J., Sadeghi M., Kazemi Qala. Professional ethics is an inevitable necessity of today's organizations. Asr Management Magazine, fourth year, numbers 17 and 16, Mehr 1389, pp: 63-58. [1] Ghasemi, H. Professional ethics necessity or choice. Development Magazine, spring 2010, pp: 91-87.

    [1] . Dehghan Manshad, p. Identifying and ranking factors affecting professional ethics. Entrepreneur Magazine, No. 86, August and September 2010, pp: 62-60. [1] Burhani, F., Al-Hani, F., Mohammadi A., Abbaszadeh A. Nursing students' understanding of barriers to acquiring professional ethics: a qualitative research, developmental steps in medical education. Journal of the Center for Studies and Development of Medical Education, Volume 8, Number 1, 2013, pp: 67-80. [1] American Nurses Association. Nursing: Scope and standards of practice. Silver Spring, MD: Nursingbooks.org. (2004).

Examining the attitude of nursing students of Gilan University of Medical Sciences towards academic dishonesty, neutralizing behaviors, nursing ethics codes and commitment to ethical care in 2010-2018.