Investigating the place of reason and emotion in moral education from the point of view of professor Motahari

Number of pages: 154 File Format: word File Code: 29876
Year: 2014 University Degree: Master's degree Category: Educational Sciences
Tags/Keywords: Affection - intellect - Moral education
  • Part of the Content
  • Contents & Resources
  • Summary of Investigating the place of reason and emotion in moral education from the point of view of professor Motahari

    Master's Thesis

    History and Philosophy of Education Department

    (Islamic Education and Training)

    Abstract

    Ethics and moral education is considered one of the most important human issues of schools and especially human education. Because moral education provides happiness and salvation. The category of ethics has various dimensions such as reason and emotion. Intellect and emotion are two high human values ??which, like other human values ??in the past, were mixed by God in the human yeast. Human beings reach the perfection worthy of a human being when they use these two powers appropriately and with correct measurement.

    The aim of the present research is to examine the place of reason and emotion in moral education from the point of view of Prof. Motahari. Considering its subject and purpose, this research is considered as applied research and its research method is descriptive-analytical (content analysis) and the method of collecting information is library.

    The first question of the research is: What is the place of reason in moral education from Professor Motahari's point of view? From the total opinions of Professor Motahari, it can be deduced that perfect morality is morality that is based on the strength of reason and will, and that all human emotions and desires are under the control of reason. A moral work is a work done according to reason, and a moral person is someone whose existence is ruled by reason. Intellect is a force that, if used correctly, recognizes good morals and considers adherence to them for the good of society and one of its own perfections. He also knows ugly morals and considers committing them to the detriment of his worldly and carnal life and the society. If the soul has the benefit of wisdom, it will consider all the realities of life wisely. Every good deed that wise people praise and people call moral, its foundation is wisdom. The second research question: What is the place of affection in moral education from the point of view of Professor Motahari? With the investigations done in Professor Motahari's opinions, it is understood that he considered emotions far from wisdom as false and unacceptable. Gradually, as our intellectual powers develop, moral virtues are created in us, and after that, our emotional responses become compatible with what our intellect recognizes. Therefore, due to the compatibility between reason and emotion, and in fact, emotions follow reason, natural tendencies are in a state of balance and are accelerated with the help of reason, otherwise emotions alone do not create any motivating and cognitive role in ethics.

    key words: reason, emotion, moral education. It has put today's people in front of many problems and the successive scientific and technical successes have created this feeling in the modern man that he does not need the moral dimension. (Warnock, Fanai translation, 1380, p. 140)

    The growth of extensive experimental and biological research made man to be assumed as an evolved animal and the moral aspects of man are considered only to the extent of physical interactions and cellular changes. (Berzinka, translated by Baybordi, 1371, p. 30) and on the other hand, generalizing the logic of the machine age and the productivity of the assembly line to humans caused them to be treated like machines. (Gotek, translated by Pak Sarasht, 1380, p. 163)

    If we consider education to be a free approach to the values ??that provide the basis for human evolution, we find that with all the progress that has been made in the field of science and technology, no change has occurred in the evolution of humans and even this progress has caused them to degrade and turned them into people who turn away from values, which is an example of Nietzsche's words that belittle modern man. has been (Naqibzadeh, 1376, p. 194)

    The most important purpose of divine revelation is the education of man, and reason, which is the essence of the divine spirit, was given to this creature as the prominent element of man to ensure the realization of this purpose. In addition to the great power of reason in man, there is another great and stunning power called emotion, which is a reflection of the human soul in the field of God-knowledge and altruism, and this spiritual manifestation is one of the prominent characteristics of Mamdoha and is the guarantor of happiness, personality, perfection, security and status of a person. This type of education provides the basis for humanization and human happiness.During the past periods, many philosophers and human thinkers and religious leaders have paid attention to this issue in some way.

    In this chapter, we intend to state the problem, the importance and necessity of the research, the objectives of the research, both general and partial objectives, and the research questions (main and secondary questions) and the definition of the terms intellect, emotion, education, ethics, and moral education so that the reader is more familiar with the generalities of the present research.

    1-2-Statement of the problem

    Ethics and moral education are considered to be one of the most important human issues of schools, especially human education. Because moral education provides the means of human happiness and salvation. According to Motahari (1383), the Holy Prophet (PBUH) says: "I have been sent and inspired to perfect morals." The category of ethics has various dimensions, such as the dimension of reason and emotion, and they should be paid attention to in the topic of moral education.

    Intellect and emotion are two noble human values ??that, like other human values ??in the past, have been mixed by God in the leaven of man. Undoubtedly, each of the two great forces of reason and emotion have an independent and effective contribution in ensuring human happiness and well-being. Mankind will achieve human perfection when he uses these two great powers appropriately and with correct measure. Ensuring prosperity and health and movement of society requires harmony, empathy, cooperation and cooperation of reason with emotions and feelings. Weakness and lack of any dynamic, but the principle of movement of the individual and society in the path of education, growth and excellence, will cause huge and irreparable damages. Reason is the guide and guide of man towards perfection. The rule of reason is based on reasoning and proof, and it is based on calculation and logic. emotions; It is a powerful driver, a force and a dynamic arm, a strong brake, and an aggressive deterrent and reprimand. Emotion does not deal with calculation, does not know logic, and is alien to reasoning and argument. Just as the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of God be upon him, has emphasized people to think about the issues of life, he has also encouraged, encouraged, and enjoined them to love, kindness, and compassion. The role of emotions in human life is unquestionable, and human life is influenced by his emotions in all stages of development, even in infancy, and his personal and social behavior is affected by them in some way. Even the mental and intellectual health of a person depends on his emotional health. (Beheshti, 1380, p. 570)

    Socrates mentions the deep relationship between reason and morality, in such a way that he believes that knowledge is the basis of virtue. Socrates is one of the first people who consciously appeals to the arguments of reason to answer the question of how each person should live and uses appropriate methods to use reason to solve this problem. Therefore, Socrates expresses a rationalistic moral theory focused on virtue. (Warnock, Fanai translation, 1380, pp. 14-28)

    Aristotle considers the goal of moral life to be happiness through the strict implementation of rational activities. (Aristotle, translated by Pour Hosseini, 1381, p. 83)

    Wilson examined the role of reason in moral education in relation to people's interests, logical compatibility with oneself, knowing facts and applying these skills in practice. (Elias, translated by Zarrabi, 1385, pp. 88-89)

    Kohlberg also considers the place of reason in moral education very important and considers reason as a process of excellence in which moral principles are used as solutions to solve problems. (Ibid., pp. 91-92)

    Hurst and Peters both consider moral education as a context in which a person can provide the context for rational education. (Ziba Kalam, 1384, p. 35)

    Harry Sheffield believes that the purpose of education is to raise a person in such a way that he can choose moral affairs in a free choice, not to provide a series of information and answers to the child

    . As a result, the main goal of moral education is the growth and flourishing of intellect.

  • Contents & References of Investigating the place of reason and emotion in moral education from the point of view of professor Motahari

    List:

    Table of Contents

    Title

    Chapter One: General Research.   1

    1-1- Introduction. 2

    1-2- Statement of the problem. 3

    1-3-The importance and necessity of research. 6

    1-4- Research objectives. 7

    1-5- Research questions. 7

    1-6- Definition of terms. 8

    Chapter Two: General research. 11

           2-1- Introduction. 12

            a) First part: theoretical foundations. 12

           2-2- The concept of reason. 12

    2-2-1- The importance of reason. 14

           2-2-2- Synonyms of wisdom. 17

          2-2-3- vocabulary versus reason. 18

    2-2-4- Intellect in the Qur'an. 20

    2-2-5- Intellectual perceptions. 22

    2-2-6- types of intellect. 23

    2-3- The concept of emotion. 25

    2-3-1- The idiomatic meaning of affection. 25

    2-3-2- Affection in the Qur'an. 28

    2-3-3- Division of emotions. 30

    2-3-4- emotional states. 31

    2-3-5- The role of emotions in human life. 33

         2-3-6- Contrast between reason and feeling. 34

    2-3-7- Affection from the perspective of Islam. 40

    2-3-8- The view of Islamic thinkers. 42

           A: Rationalists. 42

    B: Emotionalists. 45

    2-3-9- The view of philosophers. 46

    A: Rationalists. 46

    B: Emotionalists. 47

    2-4- The concept of education. 48

         2-5- The concept of ethics. 49

    2-5-1- Moral education. 50

    2-5-2- The relationship between education and ethics. 54

    2-5-3- The importance of moral education. 54

    2-5-4- The place of reason and emotion in moral education. 55

    6-2- A brief description of the life of Professor Shahid Motahari. 59

    b) Research background. 62

         2-7- Dissertations. 63

    2-8- Articles. 64

    2-9- Books. 68

         2-10- Summary of the theoretical foundations and background of the research. 70

    The third chapter: research methodology. 71

           3-1- Introduction 72

            3-2- Type of research 73

    3-3- Research method 73

           3-4- Methods and tools of information gathering. 75 Chapter 4: Research findings 78

           4-2- Investigating the first research question: What is the place of reason in moral education from Professor Motahari's point of view? 79

    A) Cultivating intellectual talent. 79

           b) Reasoning in the Qur'an. 80

    c) Wisdom in hadiths. 82

    d) Intellect should be a sifter. 83

    e) Foresight. 84

    f) Freeing the intellect from social habits. 84

    g) Supporting reason against the majority. 84

    h) The necessity of the combination of reason and knowledge. 85

    i) Invulnerability to the judgment of others. 85

           j) Theoretical reason and practical reason. 86

    88

    M) piety and practical wisdom. 91

    n) The secret of the effect of piety on clairvoyance. 92

          Q) Education according to Professor Motahari. 94

    A) Ethics according to Professor Motahari. 94

    f) Why does humanity need moral and educational methods?  . 97

    p) The difference between morality and education. 98

    A) Moral support. 99

    r) Man is a bifocal being. 101

         i) The role of reason in moral education from the point of view of Professor Motahari. 102

    4-2- Examining the second question: What is the place of emotion in moral education from the point of view of Professor Motahari? . 105

    A) Affection from the point of view of Professor Motahari. 105

    b) Piousness and gentleness of emotions. 106

    c) The influence of the heart in the judgment of the intellect. 106

    d) The human soul, the source of moral feelings and a gateway to spirituality. 107

    e) Every affection is not moral. 109

    f) Morality is not limited to unfriendliness. 110

    G) Interpretation of philanthropy.110

    h) The role of emotions in moral behavior. 111

    i) The role of emotions in moral education from the point of view of Professor Motahari. 112

    4-4- Conclusion. 115

    The fifth chapter: summary and conclusion. 116

    5-1- Introduction. 117

            5-2- A brief overview of the problem, questions and research method. 117

           5-3- Results. 118

    5-3-1- Summary of the results related to the first question. 118

    5-3-2- Summary of the results related to the second question. 119

           5-3-3- Analysis of the place of reason and emotion in moral education. 120

           5-4- Limitations. 124

           5-5- Suggestions. 125

    A) Research proposals. 125

    B) Practical suggestions. 125

    List of sources. 126

    English abstract. 137

    Source:

    A) Persian sources

    Abutalebi, Mahdi. (1383). Religious education from the perspective of Imam Ali (AS). Qom: Imam Khomeini Educational and Research Publication Center.

    Aristotle. (1381). Good manners of Makhs. Translated by Abolqasem Pour Hosseini, Ch2. Tehran: University of Tehran.

    Arafi, Alireza, Fathali Khani, Mohammad, Fasihizadeh, Alireza, Faqihi, Ali Naghi. (1388). Opinions of Muslim scholars in education and its foundations. The first volume. Tehran: Side.

    Plato. (1357). Republic Translated by Mohammad Hassan Lotfi. Tehran: Kharazmi.

    Elias, John. (1385). Philosophy of education and training (old and new). Translated by Abdul Reza Zarrabi, Q2, Qom: Imam Khomeini Educational and Research Institute (RA).

    Eimani, Mohsen. (1378). Intellectual education. Tehran: Amir Kabir Publishing House. Bagheri, Khosrow. (1377). Basics and methods of moral education. Tehran: Publications of Islamic Propaganda Organization. Berzinka, Wolfgang. (1371). The role of education in today's world. Translated by Mohammad Afaq Baybordi. Tehran: University Publishing Center.

    Beheshti, Ahmed. (1385). Child education in today's world. Qom: Bostan Kitab.

                         . (1390) Islam and child rights. Qom: Bostan Kitab. Second edition.

    Beheshti, Saeed. (1383). Analysis and critique of Kant's educational philosophy with emphasis on his educational theory. Soroush Andisheh, Sed and Radio Publishing.

    (1386). Wisdom culture. Tehran: Institute of Contemporary Knowledge and Thought.

                        (1389). Philosophical reflections on education and training. Tehran: Islamic Propaganda Organization. 14- Beheshti, Mohammad.  (1380). Emotional education from the perspective of Amir al-Mu'minin (AS). Quarterly Journal of Islamic Education. The fourth book.       

    15-                   . (1380). A collection of articles of the conference on education in the life of Imam Ali (AS). Tehran: Center for Islamic Studies. 16- Bostani, Asghar. (1380). Explanation of Allameh Tabatabai's (r.a.) value theory and its implications on moral education (goals and content). "Unpublished master's thesis". Tarbiat Madras University.

    17- Biyabangard, Ismail. (1390). Research methods in psychology and educational sciences. Tehran: Doran Publishing House.

    18- Taishman, Jenny and Graham White. (1379). European philosophy in the new era. Translated by Mohammad Saeed Hanai Kashani. Tehran: Center Publishing.

    19- Pourpour Ravandi, Qasim. (1390). The place of reason in religious education from the point of view of Allameh Tabatabai. Religious Research Journal of Kashan University.

    20 - Piaget, Jean.  (1373). Five psychological discourses. Translated by Ahmad Mohseni. Tehran: Foundation Publishing.

    21- Javadi Amoli, Abdullah. (1370). The stages of ethics in the Qur'an. Seventh edition. Qom: Isra Publishing Center.

    22 -                          (1387). Tasnim Volume 11, second edition. Qom: Esra Publishing Center.

    23- Haj Babaei, Fatemeh. (1381). Emotional education from the perspective of Imam Ali (AS). "Unpublished master thesis".

    24- Haji Baba Ian Amiri, Mohsen. (1388). Method of practical moral education in Islam. Tehran: Soroush.

    25- Hafez Nia, Mohammad Reza. (1389). An introduction to research methods in humanities. Tehran: Samt.

    26- Hosseini, Ali Akbar. (1379). "Islamic education (basics, sources and principles)". Tehran: Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies.

    27- Dashti, Mohammad. (2015).

Investigating the place of reason and emotion in moral education from the point of view of professor Motahari